| NCAA Division III All-America (NGCA) |
| Name |
Year (Team)
|
| Carrie Detjen |
2002-03 (Honorable Mention) |
| Markka Farrington |
2000-01 (Honorable Mention), 2001-02 (Second) |
| Amy Simon |
2003-04 (Honorable Mention) |
| Cheryl Treadwell |
2003-04 (Honorable Mention) |
| Jennifer Young |
2003-04 (Second), 2004-05 (Second), 2005-06 (Second), 2006-07 (Second) |
| NCAA Division III Coach Of The Year (NGCA) |
| Name |
Year |
| Kris Schoonover |
2002-03* |
| * Co-Coach of the Year |